Ok confession time.
I am a cookie lover and I always have been. As a result I have eaten and baked a lot of cookies and it would probably not be out of the question to call me a cookie connoisseur.
So when I tell you I have found a recipe you should try it's definitely worth listening.
And then when I tell you the base has only 4 ingredients your interest should be piqued.
But when I tell you they are insanely easy and can be customised by adding your own favourite add ins you should be asking yourself why you're not already baking these magical cookies.
If you saw last week's post where I put different cookie shaping techniques to the test you might recognise these beauties. They are the recipe I used for my little bake off. Specifically because they are so consistent and easy to make.
And today I'm sharing the recipe because, honestly, it's THE BEST cake mix cookie and it's too good not to share.
The ones in the top photo are pretty much no rest baked straight from mixing so they really are the ultimate low maintenance cookie.
And you can change it up and add any kind of mix in you like, the possibilities are endless.
Cake mix cookies are not my original invention they've been around for years but this recipe is a tweaked combination from a number of my favourite traditional cookie recipes I have been using for years.
I've turned the humble cake mix cookie into something pretty special using these 4 secrets.
Secret 1 - cream cheese makes a softer more tender cookie.
By using a mixture of cream cheese and butter, you get the flavour of butter but that magical softness that cream cheese brings. If you love crisp, hard cookies, this one might just change your mind.
Don't get me wrong, there is still a crisp golden crust, but the inside is more tender and soft.
Also it kinda puffs the cookie up and helps it hold it's shape more that just butter which helps with your thick cookie base.
Secret 2 - Use egg yolks instead of whole eggs for a thicker cookie.
Egg yolks add extra richness and tenderness to the dough and help the cookies to puff up as they bake and hold their shape. This works out well in this cookie as we are looking for a soft centre while still aiming for a thick cookie.
It's one of the things that helps this cookie with it's thick bakery style appearance.
Secret 3 - Use add ins that you love!
Don't skimp on your add-ins!
This is what brings the flavour party to your mouth so I know I always say this, make sure you are using chocolate you would actually like to eat.
With these cookies I went with a classic cookies and cream combination that pairs beautifully with the soft vanilla cookie base.
Secret 4 - Save some of your add-ins for the top to level your cookies up.
Want to know how to get that amazing abundant cookies look without your add-ins burning to a crisp.
Save some of your add-ins and pop them on towards the end of baking or even easier add them afterwards.
It's such a simple trick but it makes such a difference to the finished look.
Final bonus tip - Cake mix does all the hard work (I kind of gave this secret away with the title).
WHAT!!!! Cake mix! How do they taste so good?
I used to be a total from scratch snob, but I've realised there is nothing wrong with taking a short cut when it makes sense.
Just a serious note though on cake mix. Did you know that cake mix weight is different not just in different countries but between brands? I've used an Australian generic cake mix that said it was 340g but actually weighed in at 350g which is pretty similar to most Australian mixes (once you subtract frosting).
However in the US most boxes weigh 15.25oz so I've done up 2 different recipes below one for US one for Australian.
But to add another spanner to the works if you are using US Betty Crocker they come in at 13.25oz so in that case just follow the Australian recipe.
If your cake mix is different leave a comment here with the weight, on YouTube, Instagram or Facebook and I will respond to the comment with the amended recipe.
I've also done up a quick couple of minute Video where you can see how easy it is to whip these cookies yourself. CLICK HERE if you find watching someone do it helpful.
And if you didn't see last week's post you should check it out. I did a bake off between different shaped cookies to see which shaping technique made the best thick cookies. The results surprised me and I've included all the details you can check it out HERE.
Happy Baking
XX
Linda M
The Very Best 4 Ingredient Thick Cake Mix Cookie Recipe
These 4 ingredient cake mix cookies are thick, soft and incredibly easy to customise. The addition of cream cheese makes them extra tender, while the simple cake base mix means you can have homemade cookies ready in next to no time.
Use the second table to add extra ingredients for cookies and cream version.
| Australian Recipe (Or US Betty Crocker) makes 12 regular or 6 large cookies |
US - American makes 16 regular or 8 large cookies |
|---|---|
| I packer cake mix (340g) | 1 box cake mix 15.25oz |
| 55g Butter | 2.5 oz Butter |
| 55g Cream Cheese | 2.5 oz Cream Cheese |
| 2 XL egg yolks | 3XL egg yolks |
Cookie and Cream Level Up
| Australian Recipe (or US Betty Crocker) makes 12 regular or 6 large cookies | US - American makes 16 regular or 8 large cookies |
|---|---|
| 22 Oreos - 10 Oreos for baking *see note plus 6 to 12 optional extra for decorating | 29 Oreos - 13 Oreos for baking *see note plus 6 to 16 optional extra for decorating |
| 150g or 1 scant cup white chocolate chips | 7 1/2 oz white chocolate chips or 1 1/3cups white chocolate chips |
* I used a bar of cookies and cream chocolate melted to decorate the cookies with extra whole Oreos on top. You will need 1 extra Oreo per cookie you make so if you are making 12 cookies you will need 12 extra Oreos.
1. Mix together the cake mix, butter and cream cheese in the bowl of a stand mixer at low speed until the mixture looks like a fine sand and is evenly distributed, add egg yolk and mix at medium low speed until combined. That's it for the base your done, jump to step 4 if you're not making the cookies and cream version.
2. If making the Cookies and Cream version cut the Oreos you are using in the cookie dough into chunks.
3. Add the white chocolate chips and mix at low for a few seconds and once mixed in add the chopped cookies and mix a few seconds more until the add-ins are evenly distributed. Do not overmix at this stage or you will break up the Oreos too much and end up with crumbs instead of nice chunks.
4. Line 2 to 3 trays with baking paper.
5. Scoop the mixture into cookies See the headings in the ingredients list for how many cookies your recipe will make for regular or large.
6. Pop trays into fridge while you heat up the oven.
7. Preheat oven to 160 C (fan forced) 360F.
8. Cook for 12-15 minutes until they are just the way you like them.
9. Remove from oven and allow to cool on trays.
10. Optional if making the cookies and cream version you can top your cookies with extra cookies and cream chocolate and a whole cookie like in the pictures.
Original photos and recipe from the Bubble and Sweet blog. © Linda McCubbin 2026.
Linda McCubbin is the baker, blogger, maker and cookbook author behind Bubble and Sweet. With years of experience in commercial baking, café ownership and recipe development, Linda shares delicious, achievable baking recipes, creative ideas and tips to help home bakers create beautiful bakes from scratch.
Affiliate links and advertising on this blog may earn me a commission, but all ideas, opinions and recommendations are my own.


No comments:
Post a Comment