Sunday, November 10, 2013

Butter versus Oil a comparison using Betty Crocker Vanilla cake mix

I might not have mentioned this in the past but I like butter. I like the taste, I love how it whips up to make a delicious buttercream, how it makes my pancakes turn crisp and golden when I use it in my fry pan and the way it melts into my cheesy garlic bread. 

So now we've established I really (really) like butter, I have to admit I don't always use it, sometimes oil works out better. It depends on the recipe. Oil can result in a moister cake, it makes better salad dressing and works best in marinades.

Anyhoo, I noticed on the back of the new Betty Crocker cake mixes that there is an option to make them with oil and water, instead of the butter and milk. I thought it was interesting so I did a comparison using Betty Crocker Vanilla Butter Cake Mix.

I followed the easy directions on the packet exactly the same for both cakes - just replacing the butter with canola oil and the milk with water, popped the mix into 2 identical pans, greased and lined the same way and baked in the same oven.

So what happened?

Yup, definite difference right from go. The batter with butter and milk was light, thick and creamy. Instead of  pouring into the pan, I dolloped it out with a spatula.


The water and oil was a more fluid mixture that poured straight into the prepared pan. It was thinner and seemed a bit bubbly, so I gave the pan a few taps on the bench to try and loosen any air bubbles. The top was completely level.

Then I popped both pans into the oven using the fan forced option at the temperature recommended on the box and baked until a skewer inserted came out dry.

Visual Test

Bit of a surprise during baking. Although the top of the butter and milk cake was not level before baking the cake rose evenly. In fact I think if I had of lined the sides it would have been even more even. I decorate a lot of my cakes and a cake with an even top is a huge plus for me, I would barely need to trim the top of this one at all. The finished cake was a pretty uniform golden colour and sprang back nicely when touched with a dry feel. Once cut the texture inside the cake was pretty even without large air bubbles.


The water and oil cake cooked in exactly the same pan and same temperature peaked in the center when baking, it would be fine for serving the the kids looking like that but I would need to trim a heap off the middle to get an even finish if I wanted to decorate it. It required a little more cooking and was a darker colour when baked all the way through (tested with a skewer). The top of the cake felt a little sticky to touch. Once cut the cakes texture looked ok but there were a few air bubbles.

* Note I used a 22cm round spring form tin instead of the recommended loaf tin as I did not have 2 loaf tins exactly the same size.

Taste Test

I cut up samples of the cake unfrosted and we commenced a blind taste test.

Ok most of my testers were not completely reliable. My 9 year old, 7 year old and 5 year old asked how they were different, said they both tasted good and asked for more. I guess that is an answer in itself.

As for me, I could not tell a huge difference on the initial tasting, but there was a mild aftertaste of oil for the cake baked with canola oil and water. I think using a different type of oil could remedy this problem.

Verdict

I preferred the cake made with butter and milk, it definitely won the visual test hands down and for me the taste was better, although I clearly stated my fondness towards butter at the start of this post which might make me a little bit biased towards the taste.

But the kids say any cake is a good cake, so if you prefer to use oil for taste, economy or whatever reason, who am I to tell you different.

Decorating the cake in shades of pink


I couldn't let all that yummy cake go to waste so I decided to decorate the cake, by trimming the tops and sides and frosting all over with vanilla ready to use frosting. I used an extra tub of Betty Crocker Creamy Deluxe Vanilla ready to spread frosting, divided it up and added a few drops of pink food colour to make 3 different shades. Then I spread the frosting on using a butter knife in stripes graduating darker towards the bottom.


A few sugar roses* on the top and in no time I had an easy sweet shabby chic cake made with 2 packets of Betty Crocker Vanilla Cake Mix, a tub of Creamy Deluxe Vanilla Frosting some pink food colour and a knife.

* Feel free to use fresh pesticide free roses in place of sugar roses.


Linda Vandermeer is a blogger, baker, maker and author 

Disclosure: the ideas, words and opinions in this post are my own however this post was sponsored by General Mills.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

This ain't no plain vanilla Red Velvet Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe


I'm gonna let the pictures of these red velvet chocolate chip cookies speak for themselves.

Are you listening, 'cause they are saying delicious slightly chewy chocolate chip cookies with a twist.


Yup these ain't no plain vanilla cookie, Oh yeah, I've added a little raspberry to them which I know is not traditional, but sometimes I'm just crazy like that ;)

Feel free to omit the raspberry. Your choice.



Hope you love them as much as I do.

Red Velvet Chocolate Chip Cookies (makes approx 20 cookies)

220g (7 and 3/4 oz) plain (all purpose) flour
40g (1 and 3/8oz) cup cocoa
1 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
115g (4oz) unsalted butter room temperature
100g  (3 and 1/2oz) white sugar (I used caster/ superfine sugar - use regular white if you can't find superfine)
100g  (3 and 1/2oz) brown sugar firmly packed
1 egg
1 tsp vanilla extract
1/2 tsp raspberry essence
1/4tsp red food colour
85g (3 oz) milk chocolate chips
85g (3 oz) white chocolate chips



Preheat oven to 160 C. Line 2 trays with baking paper (parchment paper).

Sift together the flour, baking powder (soda), salt and cocoa.

In a large bowl cream together the butter, white and brown sugar at high speed for a few minutes until light and fluffy.

Reduce the speed to medium low and mix in the egg, vanilla, raspberry essence and food colour until combined.

Add the sifted flour mixture and mix at low speed until the mixture has just combined.

Using a spatula or large spoon mix in the white and milk chocolate chips until evenly distributed.


Spoon dough onto the prepared trays about 1 1/2 Tbsp (2 US Tbsp) in size and flatten slightly.

Bake for around 12 to 15 minutes. Remove from oven allow to rest on trays for around 5 minutes and then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.


* I often add some extra white chips by removing the tray and gently pressing about 3 into the top of each cookie about 7 minutes into baking so they look good but don't over brown :)

Cookies can be stored in an airtight container for at least 3 days.



Linda Vandermeer is a blogger, baker, maker and author of the cookbook ' Sweets on a Stick': More than 150 kid friendly recipes for cakes, candies, cookies and pies on the go!. Published in the US the book is available at most online book stores.

Original Ideas, photography and recipes by Linda Vandermeer do not reuse without permission.

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Walking Dead Nesting Doll Cookies Zombie and Daryl Dixon


Well it's out there. I'm a Walking Dead fan which is kinda strange as I really do not like horror or scary films at all.

So when I decided to make up some Zombie nesting doll cookie's I had to throw in someone from The Walking Dead and who else could it be but Daryl Dixon.

Seriously. It's not even a real competition.

Anyhoo I was pretty sure I wasn't going to be doing Daryl's arms any justice so I chose to make the cookie in the poncho outfit. Plus I find it kinda weird that the only people that look good in poncho's are 6 year old girls and Daryl Dixon. I'm not sure how that works, maybe it's the cross bow accessorizing.


The actual zombie cookies come in two types. Traditional green brain hanging out and the new walking dead inspired grey skin, gold eye and mildly more gory version (notice the missing hand).

If you follow the blog y'all would know I have some type of obsession with making stuff into nesting doll cookies (matroyoshka or babushka). If you use the search tool at the right you can find previous Halloween cookies I've made as pictured below.

Cookie instructions for Male Zombie, Daryl and fondant cross bow included below: There is a link to another post with the sugar cookie roll out recipe I use.

Daryl Dixon and Zombie Nesting Doll Cookie Instructions


Male Zombie Cookies (walking dead inspired)

These instructions use the medium nesting cookie cutter, follow the exact same instructions for small or large nesting doll cutter. For traditional green zombie replace green fondant for grey and add a partial piece of gummy brain onto the head.

Sugar cookies made using medium nesting doll cookie cutter (CLICK HERE for post with a cookie recipe)
rolled fondant shop bought or home made marshmallow fondant (Coloured Grey, White, blue, black and yellow - pink if you are making female)
small rolling pin
medium nesting doll cookie cutter (around 9.5cm or 3 3/4 inch)
small sharp knife
clean brush and water
black edible writing pen
gold dusting powder plus dry clean brush
*Fondant dries out very quickly. Use small amounts work quickly and when not in use place the fondant in an airtight container or ziplock bag to minimise the chances of it drying out and cracking.



 Roll out the grey fondant onto a clean benchtop dusted with cornflour/ cornstarch until a couple of mm (1/8") in thickness. I like to lift my fondant frequently and turn it like pie dough to ensure it does now stick to the bench while rolling it out.

Use the nesting doll cookie cutter to cut out a shape. Do the same with the black, blue and white colored fondant.


Refer to picture above as part of instructions

Place the black and blue fondant cut outs on top of each other and using the sharp knife cut out boots. Place the white cutout on top of the blue and using the knife cut a ragged shirt/pants then finally place the grey on top of the white and cut out a zombie face. Use a small amount of water to adhere the fondant cutouts onto the cookie, using the rolling pin to press into place as necessary.

Using the back of a knife or a fondant tool imprint an indent in the middle of the jeans and shoes.

With the remaining offcut head of the white fondant use the sharp knife to cut out a shoulder with ragged sleeve edges.

With the remaining offcut from the grey fondant use the sharp knife to cut out an arm and hand.Refer picture below. I gently twisted each finger to round the shape out a little, and then used the tip of a #1 piping tip to make nail indents, but just cutting the shape would be ok. On some of the cookies I did not put a whole hand and just added red fondant for a bloody stump (with a little white bone sticking out).
 

Make a second smaller arm and hand.

Adhere the shirt shoulder and larger arm to the zombie cookie as per picture and the smaller arm to the other side, the different sizes and prominent shoulder is supposed to give the allusion of lurching.

Roll out the yellow fondant and using the nesting doll cookie cutter cut out a head. Using the sharp knife cut out hair for the zombie and adhere with a small amount of water.

Using the knife, add some indents into the zombie's grey skin.

Add eyes, I used a small amount of white fondant and added yellow iris with a small amount of gold lustre dust. Any color would be ok - or you could just draw on eyes with an edible pen.

Optional - shape a small amount of grey fondant into a triangle and add a nose.

Draw on a mouth using the edible pen.

Allow to sit to until the water and pen have dried and then store in airtight containers at room temperature for up to 3 days.

Daryl Dixon Nesting Doll Cookie
*I use chocolate fondant for the dark brown, add white to make a lighter brown and mix black fondant into the chocolate fondant to make black. I just think it tastes better this way.

Sugar cookies made using medium nesting doll cookie cutter
rolled fondant shop bought or home made marshmallow fondant (Coloured Skin tone, brown, blue, black, cream, red and light brown)
small rolling pin
medium nesting doll cookie cutter (around 9.5cm or 3 3/4 inch)
small sharp knife
clean brush and water
black edible writing pen
*Fondant dries out very quickly. Use small amounts work quickly and when not in use place the fondant in an airtight container or ziplock bag to minimise the chances of it drying out and cracking.

Simple Fondant Cross Bow - the cross bow is of course optional (Umm yeah right - without it he's just some weird guy wearing a poncho)

Roll out the black fondant onto a clean benchtop dusted with cornflour/ cornstarch until a couple of mm (1/8") in thickness. Use the nesting doll cookie cutter to cut out the head, then move it inwards a little and press down again to cut out the front of the cross bow. Smooth it a little with your fingertips and pull the edges up a little as shown in the picture above.

Roll a thin strip of black fondant (or use an extruder) and shape into an upside down U. Make the U very thin and long and then place the front of the crossbow onto the top of the U shape, press the ends of the U together and then cut off excess fondant.

Roll out another even thinner strip of black fondant, attach it in the middle to the back of the crossbow (see picture) and then pull each end up to the ends of the crossbow 'front'. Cut of excess with sharp knife. Allow to set for a little while on baking paper while you make the Daryl Cookie.

Daryl Dixon Cookie


I mixed together grey, blue and brown to make dirty jean color fondant, this is optional you can just use blue or grey if you like

Roll out the jean colour fondant onto a clean benchtop dusted with cornflour/ cornstarch until a couple of mm (1/8") in thickness. I like to lift my fondant frequently and turn it like pie dough to ensure it does now stick to the bench while rolling it out.

Use the nesting doll cookie cutter to cut out a shape. Do the same with the dark brown, cream and skin tone colored fondant.

Place the dark brown and jean color fondant cut outs on top of each other and using the sharp knife cut out boots. Place the cream cutout on top of the jean color and using the knife cut a deep V for the bottom of the fondant then finally place the skin tone on top of the white and cut out Daryl's face. Use a small amount of water to adhere the fondant cutouts onto the cookie, using the rolling pin to press into place as necessary.

Using the back of a knife or a fondant tool imprint an indent in the middle of the jeans and shoes.

Roll out the lighter brown fondant and using the nesting doll cookie cutter cut out a head. Using the sharp knife cut out chunky asymmetrical hair and adhere with a small amount of water.

Roll out the red fondant and cut into thin strips, adhere around the neck and hem of the 'poncho'. then make small triangles and decorate the poncho (see picture above for example).

Shape a little excess light brown fondant into a moustache and beard - see picture above for example.carefully adhere with a tiny amount of water.

Use the edible black pen to draw on extra detail. I added dots along the red poncho trim and in the middle and side of the red design on the poncho.

Add eyes, arched eyebrows and a mouth. Make sure he's not really smiling too much.


Place the crossbow onto Daryl's shoulder adhering with a very small amount of water.

Allow to sit to until the water and pen have dried and then store in airtight containers at room temperature for up to 3 days. 

Daryl Dixon is a fictional character from The Walking Dead.



Linda Vandermeer is a blogger, baker, maker and author of the cookbook ' Sweets on a Stick': More than 150 kid friendly recipes for cakes, candies, cookies and pies on the go!. Published in the US the book is available at most online book stores.

Original photography and recipes by Linda Vandermeer for Bubble and Sweet do not reuse without permission.